About Old Town Companies

Old Town has become one of the most diverse real estate development companies in the state, having successfully taken multiple large scale developments from idea inception to completion. The company has grown rapidly through a willingness to collaborate with diverse industry partners and community stakeholders to successfully complete projects that add value by enhancing quality of life through thoughtful design and construction practices.

Justin Moffett - Chief Executive Officer

Justin founded Old Town Design Group with partner Jeff Langston in 2009. Their initial vision of a home building company that exclusively builds in outstanding locations with timelessly designed architecture quickly captured the market’s attention. Under their combined leadership, Old Town expanded beyond home building and has become one of the most diverse real estate companies in Central Indiana having led the development of several noteworthy mixed-use projects including Midtown Carmel, which transformed a former industrial yard into an award-winning community landmark.

In 2018 Justin shifted his professional focus to building a diversely talented team for the formation of Old Town Companies, which endeavors to pursue community-focused development projects that enrich the lives and well-being of our neighbors. Justin is a lifelong resident of Carmel and lives with his wife Jennifer and their four sons along the Monon Trail. In his free time, Justin is an avid runner, snow skier, and gardener, but leaves the weed pulling to his wife, for which he loves her dearly.

jeff langston - partner, Old Town Design Group

Jeff is responsible for the project management of the home construction phase of the project. Under his management, Old Town Design Group has grown to annual revenue of over $45M from new home construction alone. Jeff grew up in a family of custom homebuilders, so his passion for creating unique home designs runs deep. As the owner and operator of Indiana’s award-winning Heartwood Custom Homes, Jeff gained over a decade of construction management experience. After joining forces with Justin, Jeff put his expertise to work crafting Old Town’s unique homebuilding process. Jeff currently serves on the board of directors for the Builders Association of Greater Indianapolis (BAGI).

Ryan Weyer - Senior vp of development

Ryan is a 25-year veteran in the commercial real estate and multifamily industries. He’s responsible for the coordination and management of the pre-construction process from conceptual budgeting through final subcontractor purchasing. He leads design oversight and constructability reviews to ensure projects stay on target. Ryan’s focus on design reviews ensures the company is designing cost-effective, efficient and functional ways to construct their projects. Prior to working at Old Town Companies, Ryan refined his skills working for Trinitas Ventures, Pepper Construction, Thompson Thrift and Lauth Property Group.

Ryan earned his Bachelor of Science degree in construction management from Indiana State University and is LEED AP BD+C accredited.

Beyond work, Ryan enjoys boating and sports with his blended family of four and wife Alli.

Kyleigh Savage - Controller

Kyleigh Savage joined Old Town as Assistant Controller. She assists with accounting and construction draw functions, as well as the reporting and compliance processes. Kyleigh is a CPA and has an MBA and B.S. in Accounting. She previously worked as a tax accountant, primarily focusing on preparing and reviewing tax returns in the private equity group space. Her prior experience with federal tax compliance work will help with Old Town tax compliance.

Kyleigh and her husband, Brock, and their beloved miniature dachshund Bailey live in Anderson, where they enjoy being close to family and friends and serving at Anderson First Church of the Nazarene.

Rebecca McGuckin- Chief culture officer

Rebecca is expert at community building and promoting collaboration among a diverse group of stakeholders. Her focus with Old Town is to support projects by working with city governments, community residents, and local leaders to gather information and feedback that Old Town uses to improve the communities we build. Rebecca’s strong project management and interpersonal skills allow her to gain trust and foster relationships that result in successful development projects that enrich the lives of our residents.

Throughout her career, Rebecca has led personal and professional growth for individuals and organizations by helping them gain clarity and creating actionable steps for the implementation of business plans, goals and educational pursuits. She holds a M.Ed. from Indiana Wesleyan and a B.A. from Purdue University. As a recent graduate of the Hamilton County Leadership Academy, she continues to expand her intent for local, positive impact. She delights in supporting her four children in their pursuits, while also seeking more ways for her husband to travel the world. Meanwhile, she keeps calm stateside as a yoga instructor.

Kami Deckard - Senior Staff Accountant

Kami joined the team as the staff accountant for both Old Town Companies and Construction. She supports them through accounting, pay application process, and AP/AR. Kami holds an associate degree in accounting, bachelor’s in business management, minor in accounting, and is currently pursuing her MBA from Anderson University (graduating spring of ’23).

Prior to joining Old Town, Kami led the IT Department on a college campus where she pioneered a paperless system which built forms and workflows. While the tech world was fulfilling, Kami’s love of numbers and childhood dream of being an accountant moved her to pursue a new career.

Kami lives in Alexandria with her husband, Danny, daughter, Jordan (a freshman in nursing), and son, Carlin. When not cheering on Carlin’s baseball team, her second favorite pastime is a family, lake vacation in the camper.

Kyle May - Chief Financial Officer

Kyle leads all Old Town's accounting and construction draw functions as well as oversees project reporting and compliance. Kyle is a CPA and has an MBA and B.S. in Accounting and Business Administration. He previously served as Controller for Flagship Enterprise Center and Bankable where he helped grow the organization by 30 million in loan originations and 150% increase in total assets in six years. As Adjunct Accounting Professor and Enactus Director of Entrepreneurship with Anderson University, Kyle developed an interactive curriculum that led to students' success in the creation of new businesses through collaboration and implementation. 

Kyle, his wife, Hilary, and their two rescue dogs recently moved to Westfield where they also run an Etsy business in their free time.

KIMBERLY HANSEN - Chief operating officer

Kimberly Hansen joined Old Town as Vice President of Finance, focusing on lender relationship management and project financing. 

Before joining Old Town, Kimberly previously worked at Herman & Kittle Properties, Inc. and Trinitas Ventures, LLC where she led development efforts and managed closings for over $200 million in student housing, affordable, and market-rate development throughout the US. During Kimberly’s tenure at Trinitas, she led all development activities from initial site due diligence through site construction. Prior to focusing on real estate development, she worked in commercial mortgage loan production for a local insurance company. Kimberly’s favorite part of the job is getting to meet new people and make connections on a daily basis.

Kimberly holds an MBA from IU-Kelley School of Business and a Bachelor of Arts from Bucknell University. 

When not reimagining financial solutions or engaging integral business relationships, Kimberly may be found delighting in her husband and two young children, dreaming about her next beach vacation, sipping coffee, or going on an early morning run.

Curtis Sattison - VP of Development - Project Executive

Curtis Sattison joined Old Town as Vice President of Construction. A Purdue graduate with a Bachelor of Science degree in Building Construction Management, Sattison is leading efforts to rezone the Provenance site at Purdue and is responsible for overall management of site and building construction of all developments at Old Town. He was previously with Compass Construction and Wilhelm Construction and brings with him strong project management skills and construction knowledge.

Casey Contos - Director of Financial Planning & Analysis

Casey comes to Old Town with 16 years of banking and lending experience.  He analyzed commercial loan proposals for approval.  His favorite and most rewarding part was to simultaneously manage credit risk and serve clients with capital resources to see their impact. 

Casey obtained his Bachelor of Science degree in Commerce and Business Administration from The University of Alabama.  He then obtained his MBA from Anderson University. 

Away from work, Casey and his wife Jen are raising four kids and three dogs.  He has been a competitive water skier for 32 years, and he enjoys all things outdoors. 

Kelly Mitchell - Director of Investor Relations

Kelly Mitchell, as a former Indiana State Treasurer from 2014 to 2022, managed $16 billion in state funds and led various state authorities. Prior to this, she served as a Cass County Commissioner, earning recognition for her impactful community initiatives. Kelly’s experience brings financial expertise and transparency to build on our trusted relationships with stakeholders.  Kelly holds a B.A. in Political Science from Valparaiso University and two M.A. degrees, one in Philanthropic Studies from Indiana University and one in Strategic Studies from the U.S. Army War College. She's been honored with several prestigious awards, including the Sagamore of the Wabash and the Jesse M. Unruh Award for her distinguished service to Indiana and to the National Association of State Treasurers. Outside of work, Kelly enjoys family life in Carmel with her husband Larry, their blended family of four children and two grandchildren, and actively participates on several community boards.

Jeremy Lollar - VP of Development - Project Executive

Jeremy is responsible for new project entitlement and overall management of site and building construction. Before joining Old Town Jeremy previously held various positions with the City of Westfield, most recently the Chief of Staff.  Prior to that Jeremy was the Director of Public Works where he led the design and construction of Grand Junction Plaza and many other park and infrastructure projects. 

Outside of work, Jeremy enjoys traveling with his wife Jessica and their two daughters, boating, and spending time at the lake.   

Ben VAndeman - Community Maintenance and Landscape Manager – Project Executive

Ben supports the Old Town team in project management and the ever-expanding construction side of new development projects. He also serves as direct oversight in all maintenance and landscaping items for Old Town developments.
He joined the team with more than 25 years of experience in the world of construction and development.  He and his family represent 6 generations from the Indy southside.

He has also maintained a lifelong commitment to local and international nonprofit work and always striving to care for, serve and support the communities he is a part of.

Ben and his wife Abby share four lovely daughters.  They cherish spending family time together and being with friends.  Their whole family has great love for nature and anything outdoors.